Dear Cecily,
I’ve decided that When Harry Met Sally is a destructive Romantic Comedy to base my hopes and dreams of relationships on, so what movies can replace it in my number one “I hope this happens to me” romantic comedy slot?
Actually… I think When Harry Met Sally is actually not too bad, to tell the truth. Boy meets girl, boy is insufferable asshole, boy grows into much less insufferable asshole, girl become prissy snippy asshole, and eventually they become friends and after years of lovely friendship realize they are in love.
Since my marriage is based on the fact that my husband is basically Lloyd Dobbler of Say Anything, I really can’t fault you on the choice of When Harry Met Sally. After all, you could have made some FAR worse choices. For instance, right now my daughter is watching Beauty and the Beast for the 9,000 time and guess what? In that movie, the heroine falls for a guy with dog legs and fangs that’s basically an abusive prick.
Or maybe you could choose another Meg Ryan classic, You’ve Got Mail, in which Attractive Owner of Monolith Bookstore Tom Hanks obliterates her family’s bookstore and her livelihood, but it’s okay, because she really wanted to write fucking children’s books and besides, he’s rich (oh my GOD, that movie made me so furious). Or maybe the even worse Meg Ryan vehicle Kate and Leopold in which a smart, attractive business woman tosses it all aside to live in the literal past where she’s reduced to being her man’s property!
Shit. Okay. You’re totally right. No Meg Ryan movies for you. Not even When Harry Met Sally.
Let’s switch to Sandra Bullock. How about While You Were Sleeping? Girl meets boy, saves boy’s life, but boy is in coma, girl pretends to be engaged to boy, boy’s family embraces girl including highly attractive brother of boy, then boy wakes up and turns out to be an insufferable prick, girl leaves insufferable prick at hospital alter and is then proposed to romantically by boy’s brother and whole family in a subway booth?
Yes. I think that one works well, and all happens in the lovely city of Chicago. Clearly, you need to immediately get a job as a ticket booth jockey at the CTA, then pick an attractive rich man to save from death so you can fall in love with his brother. Done!







you forgot city of angels… how cool would it be to have an angel fall in love with you, fall from grace for you and then you die!
Oh, god! (No pun intended) That movie gives me HIVES. (And makes me crave pears. Go figure.)
Fantastic advice, but I live near D.C. Do you think it’ll have the same impact when I save a man from a Metro train?
Plus, I’m clearly going to develop some staking skills to figure out which ones are rich enough to be saved!
Twitter Name: bestoffates
GAH! I wish I would have read this before I went to work. Now I REALLY want to spend the day curled up watching unrealistic romantic movies.
Just as long as I don’t have to stand out in the yard hanging laundry all of the time waiting for a naked man to arrive from the past or future. Because that’s creepy. And probably a misdemeanor.
Twitter Name: debontherocks
Everyone should aspire to the love story of Tangled.
I’m not even be funny because THAT is how awesome and not cliche that movie is.
Twitter Name: missbritt
Which movie is it when the girl falls for the co-worker of the guy she is dating, doesn’t persue him because of the guy she’s dating, then the guy she’s dating dumps her for his ex-girlfriend so she gets the guy in the end? Is that a Meg Ryan movie?
Twitter Name: thedgoddess
I think my favorite rom-com is Moonstruck, even though I don’t think I could watch it now, knowing what has become of its formerly adorable stars, Cher and Nick Cage.